Peyton Smith – Coker
freshman year – 27-2, Varsity Wrestling, All Southern Illinois River to River Conference, 1st place Cumberland Tournament
sophomore year – 38-4, Varsity Wrestling, Co-Captain, IHSA State qualifier, All Southern Illinois River to River Conference, All South, 1st place IHSA Regionals
, 1st place IHSA Sectionals, 1st place Cumberland Tournament, 1st place Murdale Tournament, 1st place Lawrenceville Tournament
junior year – 42-5, Varsity Wrestling, Captain, 3rd place 138 pound class 1 A IHSA State placer, All Southern Illinois River to River Conference, All South, IHSA All State, 1st place Civic Memorial Tournament, 1st place Murdale Tournament, 1st place IHSA Regionals, 1st Place IHSA Sectionals
senior year – 43-5, Varsity Wrestling Captain, 4th place 145 pound class 1A IHSA State placer, Southern Illinois River to River All Conference, All South, IHSA All State, 145 pound 1st place Civic Memorial, 152 pound 2nd place Cumberland, 152 pound 3rd place Murdale, 1st place IHSA Regional, 3rd place IHSA Sectionals
Set the career wins record at Benton High School 154-16
2013/2014 Antonio Alvarez, Bailey Meense, Eli Roberts
2014/2015 Sage Freeze, Garrett Brachbil, Austin Headrick, Tyler Eggemeyer, Mack Mundy, Gage Haga,
2015/2016 Ariah Hart, Kyle Kalkbrenner, Jonny Darrah, Dale Ashby, Griffin Willis, James Schnerre